Talk:Melinda Jelenski

Is It Fair to Assume?
Shacob posed an interesting question:

"Is it fair to say that all the girls that went missing during TSITS is a Little Sister in Bio2?"

I'd be inclined to say "yes." It makes perfect sense. The whole reason they were taken in There's Something in the Sea is to be made into Little Sisters for Rapture.

However, that doesn't mean that they're encountered during BioShock 2. What if more girls were taken to Rapture than the ones Mark Meltzer learned about while investigating? What if Mindy was killed by a menacing Splicer? If either occurred, she wouldn't necessarily be encountered by Delta in the game. On top of all that, we never hear or see her name mentioned during the playthrough.

This stands in direct contrast to Masha Lutz who is specifically identified via text in Burial at Sea - Episode 2. It's natural to assume she was in Rapture during this time, but it's only because we get direct confirmation that we can add the BaSE2 icon to her page.

So... no we shouldn't assume she's one of the girls BECAUSE we are told. We have to minimize the supposition. That's what I think at least.

Unownshipper (talk) 07:56, December 29, 2014 (UTC)