User blog comment:Gearslover01/Plot Hole in BioShock: Infinite/@comment-27202257-20130913032840/@comment-75.36.133.143-20130913070626

Sent him back? There is no time travel under the 'multiverse' theory they claim this whole thing is supposedly based on. It is just switching to a universe (one of an infinity of infinities of parallel universes) where things just happened at a different time (20 years out of phase, similar to Tears viewing NewYork 70 years later or the others that songs from our era were plagiarized from).

None of it (the game) has any consistancy - in NONE of it are you changing anything (no 'do overs', no 'redemption') - you are just switching between universes where things happened different - where you wind up you take part in one path thinking you did something to change it (but it already existed in all those infinities in past and present and future). Elizabeth is supposed to see it all? Not really, if she only see/realizes a mote of universes with those so-called  'constants. In infinite other universes she did the opposite and every other combination in between  -- that is the definition of the actual  multiverse theory used to eliminate on inconsitancy of quantum physics theory.

Infinite 'Monument Islands' also every combination possible, ditto for Elizabeth and Booker ditto for every quark quanta.

An interesting thought - who says this 'baptism' event even caused the comstock/booker split and anything was 'changed'. All we see is one of infinite possible happenings (again, every other one happens as well in the multiverse continuum).

Even Perry Mason couldnt use the defense "The defendant was saving a possible future in a flying city from a tyrant by drowning to death  Booker DeWitt here at a baptism ceremony" to get Elizabeth (or a gang of girls calling themselves that) off from the charge of murder.