User blog comment:Kelis98/Should there be a Plothole page?/@comment-3967731-20160606015759/@comment-27600937-20160606142645

Alright.

"What matters is that each additional game is here to stay, i.e. none of them ( Burial at Sea,  BioShock 2, etc.) can be disregarded despite contradictions pointed out by the fans."

While that is true, it doensn't stop people from having canon arguments (which is why I also suggested a canon page).

Also, if you can explain these to me then go right ahead:

(This is from a post I made a while ago) Here is my explanation for the plotholes in bas, it is all I will say on the subject so here you go.

Here is my explination, but before I do I want to clarify one thing, and that is that the official bioshock canon is 1, 2, infinite, Minerva's den, and burial at sea. This has been confirmed by 2k, irrational, ken levine, and even references in the other games themselves. No that we have that out of the way lets get on with the topic. The timeline starts with burial at sea, yes it is before 1 happens but it takes place before infinite ends and in a different universe than the rest of the bioshock series. Why you ask, well this is because in bioshock 1 it is said that fontaine had direct involvement in the creation of jack. He created jacks memeories, and he knew the wyk phrase before he faked his death. One reason we know this is because he created the antidote to all the mental control including wyk and code yellow. Another reason is that in bioshock 2 it is said that delta was created after suchong died and since delta was shown on December 31 1958 (new years eve) he died before then, but in burial at sea he died two weeks later. Another reason is that the wall that Liz enters was not there in bioshock 1 it was solid concrete, and the drill wasn't broken it was a removable drill like on the alpha series. We also know that it takes place before infinite ends because it is said at the end of infinite that all Columbia's and comstocks are wiped from existance, and in bas we see comstock and go to Columbia, and since it takes place before infinite ended by the time infinite does end the rapture comestock wouldn't exist and nithier would Columbia or Elizabeth and there for with no Liz or Columbia, atlas would be stuck down in fontaine department store and the civil war wouldnt happen. That is how we know it is a different rapture. Another thing to add is that the war meantioned in some of bioshock 1s audio diaries is the gang war between fontaine/atlas and ryan not just the rapture civil war. And then it is followed by the other games So the timeline goes like this: Timeline 1: infinite (which really takes place across three versions of Columbia) Timeline 2: burial at sea, alternate bioshock 1, alternate bioshock 2, alternate Minerva's den. Timeline 3: bioshock 1, bioshock 2, Minerva's den Timeline 4: bioshock: rapture (novel) Full time line: burial at sea, infinite, bioshock rapture, bioshock 1, bioshock 2, Minerva's den <span style="font-family:helvetica,arial,sans-serif;color:rgb(29,33,41);font-size:12px;font-weight:normal;line-height:16.08px;">(Timeline=universe)