User blog comment:Bradford13131313/Bioshock Infinite 2?/@comment-78.147.118.76-20131030234807

Here's my opinion.

Clearly the events of Bioshock Infinite cannot exist due to Elizabeth drowning Booker / Comstock at the baptism correct? Maybe not. Constants and variables. Constants being the baptism, variables (as we were previously shown) consisted of Booker accepting the baptism and becoming Zachary Hale Comstock, or running away, remaining Booker Dewitt. How about another variable, Booker never making it to the baptism?

Booker instead finds out his partner is pregnant, and decides to support her and the child to try to forget about his sins. His partner dies during childbirth, and Booker becomes and alcoholic and a gambling addict through depression, racking up his debt. Booker and his daughter Anna Dewitt go on the run to try to avoid the inevitability of being killed by the powerful men who he owes the debt to if he stayed.

As for Colombia, Comstock surely never existed. However why not Fitzroy be the creator? Fitzroy, a slave brought to New York, manages to escape her captors and goes on the run, with several other coloured folk of that era. Desperate for a normal life, she comes across a scientist, Robert Lutece. Amazed by his work, she pleads and begs him to help her build an undiscoverable city, for those who are mistreated down below to live prosperous lives, and promises him great oppertunity and wealth, he clearly accepts. Worried about this city being destroyed by the white man, Fitzroy builds a guardian for the city, to protect all those who live there, a winged beast known solely as 'Songbird', programmed to destroy and kill any white man that dare enters the cities ground. Fitzroy, now the leader of Colombia, kills Robert (And Rosalind) Lutece in the same way that Comstock does, and yet again, they want revenge.

One day, a man knocks on Booker (And Anna) Dewitts hideout, and claims to dispose of the debt, in exchange for Fitzroy. Anna Dewitt, being brought up on the run, had no school, no friends, and so self taught herself everything from lockpicking to codebreaking, and even things her father was unaware of (Tears). Robert Lutece brings them both to a lighthouse, sends them on their way, and before leaving, says 'Bring us the girl, and wipe away the debt.'